Carousel *****

Joshua Henry

By: Isa Goldberg

April 24, 2018 – Revivals of Rodgers and Hammerstein’s Carousel are infrequent indeed. And this production, directed by Jack O’Brien, is a brilliant reimaging of this classic, boasting such memorable songs as June is Bustin’ Out All Over, and You’ll Never Walk Alone. That they are performed here to a full orchestra is also rare.

Read more >

Goldstein ***1/2

Aaron Galligan-Stierlle, Jim Stanek, Megan McGinnis, Amie Bermowitz

By: Isa Goldberg

April 24, 2018 – In this small stage musical, Goldstein, a Pulitzer Prize winning novelist, grapples with his feelings about his parents, his family, and growing up. By reinventing the fictions that he heard as a child; Louis, the charming Zal Owen, attempts to weed out the family lies, and deceits, to achieve an understanding of himself, and his heritage.

Read more >

Carousel ***1/2

Jessie Mueller, Joshua Henry

By: Paulanne Simmons

April 23, 2018 As Carousel is my second favorite musical of the 20th century (Showboat comes first), there’s pretty much nothing anyone could do to make me dislike a Carousel revival. And the current one, directed by Jack O’Brien, certainly has much to be commended.

Read more >

Children of a Lesser God ****

Lauren Ridloff, Joshua Jackson

By: Paulanne Simmons

April 17, 2018 – When Mark Medoff’s Children of a Lesser God first landed on Broadway in 1980, the main questions it elicited were about who should speak for the deaf and if American Sign Language should be considered as legitimate a form of communication as spoken language. 

Read more >

Nanette ****

Hannah Gadsby Photo: Carol Rosegg

By: Isa Goldberg

April 12, 2018- Making her American debut with, “Nanette,” Hannah Gadsby’s one-woman show the Soho Playhouse crosses the line from stand-up comedienne to feminist satirist, and social critic. Anger, indeed, is the stuff of some of our greatest comedians from Lenny Bruce to Joan Rivers.

Read more >

The Winter’s Tale ***1/2

Kelley Curran, Nicole Rodenburgin

By: Iris Wiener

April 10, 2018 – Forget winter; when a Shakespearean tale is produced this intelligently, it is ripe for every season. Though the writing itself is long and frustrating at times, it is made fantastically accessible in Polonsky Theatre Center’s intimate setting. Shakespeare’s lesser-known tragicomedy is a tale of jealousy, loss and redemption, while infused with bold notes of humor. Unfortunately, it takes a while to get to the funny, and those are the scenes that make this production unique and memorable.

Read more >

Three Tall Women **** Lobby Hero *** Frozen ** Admissions ****

Glenda Jackson in “Three Tall Women”

By: David Sheward

April 8, 2018 – Recycling continues to be the main mode of operating on Broadway. Two American plays (Three Tall Women, Lobby Hero) are making their belated Main Stem debuts after successful Off-Broadway engagements roughly two decades ago and yet another Disney cartoon (Frozen) is transitioning to the live stage. Meanwhile Off-Broadway, a brand-new work (Admissions) is challenging conventions and rigidly-held beliefs in a production that induces both laughs and squirms of discomfort. The Broadway revivals do the same, but it’s indicative of our large-scale commercial theater that fresh innovation is confined to our smaller stages.

Read more >

Three Tall Women *****

Alison Pill, Glenda Jackson, Laurie Metcalf

By: Isa Goldberg

April 5, 2018. While Edward Albee’s Three Tall Women, his 1994 Pulitzer Award-winning drama, is full of sadness, Joe Mantello’s revival plays on its underlying and uncanny sense of comedy. Seething beneath the fast-paced banter, in fact, is a kind of Grand Guignol, a graphic, display of amoral horror and entertainment. 

Read more >

Lobby Hero *****

Chris Evans, Michael Cera

By: Isa Goldberg

April 5, 2018. As humorous and unpretentious as Lobby Hero is, in its portrayal of everyday urban life, it’s a delving piece of theater, about the stories we tell ourselves, and others.

Read more >

Gob Squad: War and Peace **1/2

By: Paulanne Simmons

April 3, 2018 – The Berlin collective Gob Squad works collaboratively with performance, video installation and interactive theater to produce innovative and challenging works. As with all such endeavors, the results range from brilliant to mundane. Their newest work War and Peace is a little of both.

Read more >

Babette’s Feast ****

Abigail Killeen, Michelle Hurst, Juliana Francis Kelly

By: Lauren Yarger
March 30, 2018

An exquisite and tasteful staging of the New York premiere of Babette’s Feast serves up this week’s Easter message of love and grace.

Read more >

Angels in America *****

Nathan Lane and Nathan Stewart-Jarrett in “Angels in America”

Angels in America: A Gay Fantasia on National Themes

By: David Sheward

It’s been over 20 years since Angels in America, Tony Kushner’s epic two-part dramatic response to the AIDS crisis, burst onto the world stage. In spite of its age and the fact that it takes place ten years earlier (1985-6), this epic remains startlingly relevant and Marianne Elliott’s highly theatrical and insightful new production, now on Broadway after a smash run at the National Theater in London, is simultaneously massive and intimate. When the play opened (Part One—Millennium Approaches premiered in San Francisco in 1991, Part Two—Perestroika debuted on Broadway in 1994), critics predicted it would take its place alongside the masterworks of O’Neill, Williams, and Miller. This quirky, heartfelt revival confirms that status.

Read more >

Calamity Jane ****

Peter Gosik (Wild Bill Hickock); Rosalie Burke (Katie); Dallas Padoven (Ensemble); Kristin Wetherington (Calamity Jane); Caitlin Evans (Ensemble); Abby Hart (Ensemble)

By: Paulanne Simmons

In 1953, at the height of the American film and television industry’s fascination with the West, Warner Brothers released Calamity Jane, a musical loosely based on the alleged romance between Calamity Jane and Wild Bill Hickok. The film starred Doris Day in the title role and Howard Keel as Hickok, and featured a score by Sammy Fain (music) and Paul Francis Webster (lyrics).

Read more >

Admissions ****

Jessica Hecht, Andrew Garman, Ben Edelman

By: Isa Goldberg

That Admissions, Joshua Harmon’s new play at Lincoln Center’s Mitzi E Newhouse Theater, feels like it’s stuck in banalities, is much to the playwright’s point. Here, at Hillcrest, in the elite halls of the country’s leading prep school, the tyranny of political correctness is more contagious than an outbreak of the flu.

Read more >

A Letter to Harvey Milk ****1/2

Adam Heller, Julia Knitel, Cheryl Stern “A Letter to Harvey Milk”

By: Paulanne Simmons

Despite its somewhat misleading title, A Letter to Harvey Milk is not about the gay activist who was shot and killed in San Francisco by Dan White. Although Milk does make an appearance in the musical, the real hero is Harry Weinberg, an aging Jewish man, who signs up for a writing course with a young lady named Barbara Katsel and ends up writing that letter.

Read more >